Alien 3: In the Tunnels of Madness





I have the feeling that Alien 3 wanted to be something different - but it lost its way somewhere along the story.

The premises were there, it was doing really well. It has a lot more world building than its predecessors - you have all those convicts wrapped in an oddly functional system, you have their oddly shaped religious attitude, each of them has somewhat distinctive features, their world is a literal, almost derelict prison, and they even find a place for the Alien in their reality: it's the dragon.


It also has a very distinctive tone - moody and ghostly industrial in the beginning, then a bit medieval, it almost reminded me of The Name of the Rose in the first part. Bald heads, vows of chastity, sins and penitence, prayers and sermons, almost total lack of technology, cattle and hooded figures, Ripley falling from heaven among them, all seemed to promise another kind of story.
 
It also has the mysterious doctor/convict, Clemens Who Sees Through Things - but he's played by Charles Dance, so this was almost cheating :)

It almost looked like a whole new angle on the Alien story: Alien 1 had the cold, sweaty body horror and isolation, Alien 2 had the thrills curses and shoot-outs, and Alien 3 COULD have had the apocalyptic/mythical gloom.

...Except it didn't. 

The religious angle gets lost entirely along the way - I really would have liked to see how a community of alienated religious freaks react to an unspeakable demon, but after Golic's reaction and containment everything reverts to the already standard "fight xenomorph against all odds" tone.

The moodiness comes back a little in the end, in the shape of labyrinthine entrapment, but we'd been missing it for a good hour by that point.

Clemens dies way, way too soon (remember Hicks? who made it to the end of the movie?). What was the point of his "mysterious past", of his connection to Ripley? All down the drain.

And the convicts' personalities were too thin. The final chase scene was fantastic, but the convicts became too suddenly efficient for my taste. They still freaked out and "improvised" :), but overall they were pretty brave and in synch. I would have liked to see them more dysfunctional...

Maybe Alien 3 tried to bring together elements that did not belong together no matter what, and that's why it failed to be as unique as it could have been.
Not that I didn't like it, or that it might not be my favorite Alien movie. Just that it left me with a daaaaamn it was so close...

The Yojimbo Paradigm

 

Photo by Emiliano Grusovin



Here is a short exploration of 6 stories narratively related to Akira Kurosawa's movie Yojimbo.  

The title of this essay has been chosen for easy reference; the narrative itself, however, was born from a couple of Dashiell Hammett novels, namely Red Harvest (1929) and The Glass Key (1931).  




The Tale

The story line of the Yojimbo is highly watchable - it's a narrative that gives a lot of room for new elements. An extra lot of room, if you're Takashi Miike. It is one of the preciously few arch-stories that are universal enough to allow for endless re-imagining, but also specific enough to be easily recognizable. Something akin to many Biblical or Shakespearean stories - only more recent.

This narrative typically has a main character almost impossible to dislike, even when he's not quite the focus of the story (as it happens in Sukiyaki). He's almost never paired with a love interest - Miller's Crossing's Tom Reagan being the exception here, but he's so chill about it and gets The Third Man treatment so bad that we can almost ignore it.

This character is some type of badass (with a gun, with a sword, with his wits), typically unnamed, who ends up in the middle of a two-sided conflict. He attempts (and eventually succeeds) to stifle said conflict by joining the two sides alternatively and making them implode or explode. His actions are needed because the conflict wreaks havoc on its social environment (usually a small town populated by wretched innocents), and the story begins during a stalemate between the two sides. The hero lands in a bar or inn - empty and almost out of business; the owner exposes the situation and tries to persuade him to leave for his own good. He doesn't, and we don't quite know why. The town also contains some kind of joker or madman, and there is always a not-love-interest woman, separated by her family, who is forced to be the lover of one of the mob bosses. Our hero also saves the woman, which exposes his machinations to the respective mob, which in turn leads to him being beaten badly or tortured. He eventually escapes, recovers and finishes his self-imposed mission. In the end, whoever's left alive in the aftermath sees the Nameless as a savior, but he still walks, or rides, or drives away into the sunset.


 

The Variations

Of the 6 more or less Nameless Strangers, Sanjuro (Toshiro Mifune, top left) might still be the most convincing one - him and Joe (Clint Eastwood, top middle) being the ones still preserving an ounce of anti-heroism and mystery. The other 4 - Omega Doom (Rutger Hauer, bottom left), Gunman (Hideaki Ito, top right), Tom Reagan (Gabriel Byrne, bottom right) and John Smith (Bruce Willis, center) - are more obviously good guys. Still rugged, still punished at one point of the story, but obviously do-gooders. A very interesting fact is that the Yojimbo usually just happens to stumble upon his story, but more about this in the end of this essay.

This storyline lends itself seamlessly to many genres - neo-noir/hardboiled, gangster thriller, western, jidaigeki, cyberpunk, Japanese Madness with Cowboys Warring States Miniguns and Katanas. Another version of this story, Stuart Heisler's The Glass Key (1942) with Alan Ladd and Veronica Lake, is a classical film noir.
It can also be framed in many colours and styles: Yojimbo is mostly humorous, Fistful is amusing with a heavy touch of drama, Omega Doom is desolate, Last Man is gritty, Sukiyaki is insane and Miller's Crossing is lyrical.

The warring factions are also quite diverse: run-of-the-mill evil in Yojimbo and Last Man, human evil in Fistful, silly in Omega Doom, silly and creepy in Sukiyaki and entirely human in Miller's Crossing.


The Italian and the Irish bosses from Miller's Crossing

The Paradigm

This multitude of styles and angles allows us a better understanding of the core story. What is actually happening here? Let us focus a little on the motivation of the Yojimbo and several interpretations of his gritty and lovely narrative.

One possible reading of the main character is that of Deus Ex Machina, who usurps the whole storyline: we have two factions crossing and double-crossing each other into a deadlock, when suddenly someone lands between them and solves the conflict. Some critics see the Nameless character as a Horseman of the Apocalypse, setting an end time upon the old world, a harbinger of the Last Judgment. Others interpret him as the hero who saves the innocents from two terrible dragons scorching the land.

But most of these readings seem to miss something, a deeper layer, a primeval human need, more basic than justice or peace. The true core is given by a search for purpose, and the value of this story lies in the way it satisfies this need. 

Storytelling is an essential human tool, because it enables us to preserve information, it gives us context, it keeps us entertained, it connects us. Most importantly though, storytelling infuses people and events with sense and purpose. That is why we need and create stories so much. 

In the beginning of this specific tale, the Nameless protagonist is roaming around meaninglessly, just like many of us at different points in our lives. When, all of a sudden, he happens to come across a narrative, and finds a purpose for himself - that of Yojimbo, bodyguard and protector. Sure, he might be good at heart, and might genuinely want to save the innocents. However, one does suspect that he lingers around to solve the two-factions conflict out of sheer need of a story, a small oasis of sense and purpose in the desert landscape he comes from.

And, so, in spite of his devil-may-care attitude, the Yojimbo is a character in need of a story. Unlike the more unfortunate of us, he actually manages to find one. At least for a while. 


Abayo! (Bye! in Japanese, the final word of Toshiro Mifune’s Yojimbo)